We read often about homeschoolers that are engaged in outside activities; whose high schoolers have part time jobs and still excel in their studies; daily nature walks that result in wonderful discoveries; 5-year olds that can speak fluent French.
Then, we homeschoolers who do not manage to make nature walks even a weekly activity, who struggle with English grammar and take a year to get through a foreign language program {we didn’t even think about a foreign language when they were five}, who cannot imagine their high schooler getting a part time job because we are still focusing on making sure they can do the every day tasks around the house… What about us?
I was talking with a mother who homeschools on Sunday before church and while our conversation did not center around homeschooling, it really made me aware of the things they do in their day that differs greatly from what we do in ours. This mother {and her 12 year old daughter} were spouting off the names of numerous flowers that I had no idea what they were talking about. They participate in many musical activities {at a famous orchestral center perhaps} and we are barely getting into music appreciation, let alone actually playing instruments or actively singing. I won’t lie; it made me feel inadequate.
When we first began at the church we attend now, which was the end of September, we talked with the pastor about what they do with homeschooling. I know what curriculum they use and of course it’s different than what we use but I found myself comparing {bad, bad} my children’s progress with their children. Their 15 year old is advanced in math; my daughter, also 15, is right on schedule. Their science for their 3rd and 4th graders includes a lot of fun, hands-on activities; for both 7th and 9th grade, our science is quite lacking in the ‘fun’ department.
I know that our homeschooling family is not the only family (or perhaps it is just me as a parent) that feels our experience could be so much more- if it were more like those other homeschoolers.
There is nothing wrong with my homeschool. There is nothing wrong with my kids and there isn’t anything wrong with me as a teacher. {haha…dd said, jokingly “Keep telling yourself that.”} We are just different. Sometimes watching those other homeschoolers, I get the feeling that I am not doing all that I can. But all families are different.
Some families have more in the way of finances than others; that dictates a lot of what can be purchased in regards materials and curriculum as well as the opportunities that are available. Some families have more support, whether it be family members, other homeschoolers, church family, etc. People learn differently and teach differently; we make our choices {about the above curriculum, opportunities, etc.} based partially on this.
It really is never good to compare. We are all different. Bottom line. What works for one family may not work for another. This post at ChildlightUSA at first made me feel no better- but after reading it more than once {I have to do that quite often}, it did make me feel better.
My children are unique; I am unique; our learning and experiences will be unique. It doesn’t mean that my children will become ‘ordinary’ and although they may not be what some would label ‘gifted’ or ‘exceptional’ {labels, schmabels} I like what Jennifer Gagnon says:
“Just as our body types are unique to each of us, so is our heart, soul and mind. I would argue that each child has special needs and is gifted.”
The photo I added to my post is what my ds was focused on this morning before school started. There is an invasion of Bionicles, Hero Factory and Ben Ten… well, we have fun even if we don’t get all the other things fit into our day… {I will keep telling myself that}
What about you? Do you ever feel that your homeschool doesn’t quite ‘measure’ up to others? What do you do when you have those thoughts?
Blossom, I think this constantly! I was reminded yesterday that our own perceptions are often wrong when a friend of mine made a comment that struck me as funny. She was envious of me, when I can't even begin to fathom why she would be!
ReplyDeleteMany times have I thought we dont measure up! However pulling them out of public school when they were struggling it was bound to be tough! Most people seem to think all homeschoolers are geniuses or overachievers. We are each unique and have unique abilities! Great post!
ReplyDeleteI get glared at whenever I suggest that all children have special needs and are gifted. I'd never try to minimize the struggles or gifts of others, that's not my point, but our society is too quick to put everybody into this box or that box, rather than seeing each of us (yes, all of us) as individuals.
ReplyDeleteI think some comparisons can be helpful, especially in determining if a child needs special help in certain areas...but not everybody is an overachiever (I don't think we want everyone to be, do we?), not everybody is a math whiz, or a natural reader, just as we don't want everyone to grow up to be a lawyer or a doctor. There's a special place for each of us.
Thank you for a thoughtful post.
I feel that way all the time! I have to calm myself down before I add more to my day and remember that if I'm overwhelmed nothing will get done. As my children get older I realize they are turning out just fine even if they aren't ivy league material. Oh, well! Even if we all used the same curriculum we would get different results because we would have different standards for our children and different ways of using the material.
ReplyDeleteTwo thumbs up Blossom! Great post!
ReplyDeleteBlossom,
ReplyDeleteOh, this is why it's so important to know WHY you're homeschooling. I agree...the feelings of inadequacy are a constant struggle for most homeschooling moms. I think it pushes us to fix our eyes on Christ and to cement our identity in Him and Him alone.
Wonderful, thoughtful post, my friend.
I have wanted to come by and comment ever since reading this.
ReplyDeleteAlong with homeschooling, I live in an area that, generally speaking, highly values academic achievement. Not only do I often feel like the underachiever, I also feel like I am swimming up steam with my point of view.
I don't see academics as a the god some do. I often see more value in the play that our children do or the experiences they have (even playing board games). We are providing more outside experiences for our children this year than we have in the past, but I personally think that time to just be kids is the most valuable thing we can give our children.
Keep up the good work. It always looks to me like you are doing a great job!
Hi Blossom,
ReplyDeleteJust wanted to add to what everyone else has so wisely said already: keep up the good work that you're doing. Comparing ourselves to others can sometimes cause us to lose sight of our unique gifts and circumstances. Let the good work that others do inspire you, rather than make you feel inadequate!
Thanks for stopping by my blog earlier and leaving your kind comments.